Public Enemy

In recent years Korean cinema has often been touted as the next big thing. Generally one remains unconvinced. There’s a sense little is really distinctive about the films, which come across as a mix of Hollywood, Hong Kong and Japanese product looking for their place in the sun but not really offering any convincing reason as to why.

Public Enemy (Gonggongui jeog) is different, visibly trying to be a distinctively Korean genre film. But, unfortunately, it fails to ignite for this selfsame reason.

The story is a simple one with a high cliché count: A maverick cop – is there any other kind as far as film-makers are concerned? – named Kang finds himself playing cat and mouse with a psychopathic yuppie, Jo, who has murdered his own parents when they threatened to withdraw an investment.

The actors playing the two men, Kying-gu Sol and Sung-jae Lee are household names in their country while director Woo-suk Kang has established himself as someone who can blend genre film-making with social comment.

All good, but not counting for much outwith the home market. Worse, the social commentary aspects overload the piece with under-developed subplots as to who is the bigger Public Enemy – Brecht anyone? – and proves disastrous to the film's pacing and structure.

For the first 50 or so minutes we focus on Kang. Recruited into the force more for his boxing skills than anything else, he beats up suspects, openly consorts with gangsters and has a sideline in ripping off one group of drug dealers and selling their product to another. The internal affairs investigation is entirely warranted and a long time coming…

Jo gradually comes into the mix, a control freak with a loving wife and child – who, having been introduced unfortunately play no further part in the narrative – and a tendency to kill anyone who threatens him with loss of face. (Wouldn't this have become evident long before? Or is being a psychopath a positive virtue in the world of business?)

But, after Kang and Jo have the first encounter as the latter his parents – the way Jo gets the drop on Kang unconvincing and out of character – Kang suddenly transforms into the de facto hero, his earlier crimes and misdemeanours largely forgotten. Or not quite, with the tone continuing to veer between grim seriousness, with the quest to prove Jo’s guilty providing Kang with a shot at redemption, and black comedic, as when Kang gets a gangster associate to demonstrate how to kill someone with different kinds of blade.

You get the impression that the Hollywood-lite version would have established the characters of the two protagonists in ten minutes, zeroed in on the conflict between them, left the messages to Western Union and ended up with a taut 100 minute thriller instead of a 140 minute sprawling road accident.

A shame, for the performances are good, the direction intelligent and the film-makers to be applauded for their intentions in doing something other than just hybridising elements of American Psycho, Bad Lieutenant, Gang Related and – above all – Takeshi Kitano's assorted Violent Cops.

Sound and image on this Region 2 DVD from Tartan are fine, though nothing to write home about.

The most substantial extra is a 39 minute making-of promo that is best watched after the film as it contains spoilers. While hardly riveting it does give a bit of contexualisation – the film saw Sung-jae Lee cast against type and Kying-gu Sol bulk up by 30lbs for his role – which is more than can be said for the 16 minutes of outtakes that represent a challenge to sit through even once.

Three deleted scenes running five and a half minutes in total feel somewhat unnecessary given that the film could have done with pruning as it is.

The package is rounded off with a music video for all those Korean rock fans out there, the film's original trailer – which tellingly emphasises the violence and action aspects rather than the social satire – and a bevy of trailers for other Tartan Asia Extreme product.